萨提亚·纳德拉说他现在对AGI深信不疑

内容来源:https://www.theverge.com/tech/1036111/satya-nadella-says-hes-agi-pilled-now
内容总结:
微软首席执行官萨提亚·纳德拉近日在旧金山微软Ignite大会主题演讲后的圆桌讨论中表示,他在经济层面已“对AGI充满信心”,尤其关注AGI可能对经济结构和政治格局带来的深刻变化。纳德拉提出,如果智能具有网络效应,当所有人力资本都坍缩为“代币资本”时,企业的作用和人力资本在企业中的角色将面临根本性挑战。他警告说,如果只存在资本而没有劳动力,民主制度下的选举将无法正常运作,“那就不算是一种经济”。他还以一个假设性的极端情形说明垄断风险:若按照某种马克思主义式观点只允许一家企业存在,那么所有人都将受制于这一家公司,“你也会在某种程度上成为Anthropic的附属机构”。纳德拉强调,不应将当前局面仅仅视为科技公司之间争夺下一个万亿美元市值的狭隘竞争,因为模型本身没有边界,可以涉足医疗、金融服务甚至政府治理等任何领域。他认为,如果世界和经济需要不止一两家企业,那么按定义就需要与各类企业数量相匹配的多种模型,以防止权力集中化。此外,纳德拉表示他不认为Claude等前沿模型具有意识,并认同微软AI部门首席执行官穆斯塔法·苏莱曼的观点,即企业不应赋予模型权利或将其视为具有道德地位,但他同时表示自己对此并不过于教条化,认为这是一场值得讨论的辩论,而最重要的社会技术问题在于如何确保经济能够广泛扩散这项技术。
中文翻译:
微软CEO萨提亚·纳德拉表示,他已经对AGI深信不疑,至少在AI可能对经济结构产生惊人变化以及由此可能引发政治变革这一层面上是如此。“我之所以对AGI深信不疑,是因为在经济层面上,围绕AGI的政治经济学组织将会是怎样的?”他在旧金山大通中心发表微软Ignite主题演讲后的一次圆桌讨论中问道。
萨提亚·纳德拉表示他现在对AGI深信不疑
但他不认为Claude具有意识。
但他不认为Claude具有意识。
但纳德拉不认为像Claude这样的前沿模型具有意识。“我不这么认为,”他说,并补充说他认同微软AI CEO穆斯塔法·苏莱曼的观点,即公司不应赋予模型权利,也不应将其视为可能具有道德地位的存在——而像Anthropic这样的公司则将此作为原则性问题来对待。苏莱曼曾告诉我,他认为Anthropic的团队已经把自己“洗脑”了,这种做法是危险的。
纳德拉对此的态度没那么坚决。“这是一场很好的辩论,”他说。“我对此并不教条。我想说的是,我们必须面对的最重要的社会技术问题是,如何确保一个经济体能够广泛地传播这项技术?”
在听到纳德拉对另一位记者关于Anthropic在其办公套件中发布更多产品的问题的回应后,我问他如何看待AI。纳德拉长篇大论地谈到了如果允许某一个AI模型获得垄断地位,经济可能崩溃、民主可能终结。
“如果按照马克思主义的观点,只有一家公司,那就完了,对吧?对我们所有人来说都是如此。”
“大多数人把这看作是科技公司之间的竞争,这当然会是竞争的一部分,”他说。“但请记住,模型是没有边界的。它可以成为一家医疗保健公司。它可以成为一家金融服务公司。它想成为什么都可以。它可以接管政府。把这看作是科技公司之间谁能率先达到下一个万亿美元市值的狭隘竞争,是最奇怪、最狭隘的思考方式之一。”
纳德拉接着表示,公司这一事物的本质在未来将面临颠覆。“如果智能具有网络效应,那么公司的未来是什么?”他问道。“如果模型能看到任何事物并从中学习,而且基本上所有人力资本都坍缩为代币资本,那么公司的角色是什么?公司中人力资本的角色又是什么?这才是值得辩论的问题。”
“我认为在这样的背景下,政治经济学将变得越来越有意思。没有人——至少在民主国家——如果事情就这样发展下去,如果只有资本而没有劳动力,甚至都不可能赢得选举。我是说,我不知道,那就不算一个经济体了。”
“如果按照马克思主义的观点,只有一家公司,那就完了,对吧?对我们所有人来说都是如此。不只是对我。你也会在某种程度上成为Anthropic的附属机构。”
不用说,这不是科技CEO们通常谈论竞争性电子表格软件发布的方式。
当然,纳德拉也在Ignite大会上推广微软的各种AI工具,这些工具承诺让企业客户为不同任务选择最具成本效益的模型、运行自己的模型,并以不同方式控制自己的数据。其核心思路是,市场将需要多种不同类型的模型和主权数据,以防止控制权集中化——这是纳德拉在我们交谈中反复提及的主题。
“我认为,如果你相信世界和经济需要不止一家或两家公司,那么按照定义,就需要有与公司数量相当的模型,”他说。
英文来源:
Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella says he’s AGI-pilled, at least when it comes to how AI might make startling changes to the structure of the economy and how politics might change because of it. “I am AGI pilled in the sense that at an economy level, what is the political economy’s organization around AGI?” he asked at a roundtable discussion following his Microsoft Ignite keynote at the Chase Center in San Francisco.
Satya Nadella says he’s AGI-pilled now
But he doesn’t think Claude is conscious.
But he doesn’t think Claude is conscious.
But Nadella doesn’t think frontier models like Claude are conscious. “I don’t think so,” he said, adding that he follows Microsoft AI CEO Mustafa Suleyman’s view that companies should not give rights to models and treat them like they might have a moral status, which companies like Anthropic do as a matter of principle. Suleyman has told me he thinks Anthropic’s team has “wireheaded” themselves, and that this approach is dangerous.
Nadella wasn’t quite as firm about it. “It’s a good debate,” he said. “I’m not sort of dogmatic about it. What I’m saying is the most important social technical issue we have to deal with is how do you ensure that an economy can diffuse this technology broadly?”
I asked Nadella how he was thinking about AI after hearing his response to another reporter’s questions about Anthropic releasing more products in its office suite. Nadella talked at length about the potential collapse of the economy and the end of democracy if one AI model were allowed to achieve monopoly status.
“If the Marxist sort of view is that there’s only one firm, then it’s over, right? For all of us.”
“Most people think about this as a competition between tech firms, which of course it will be,” he said. “But remember, the model has no limits. It’ll be a healthcare company. It can be a financial services company. It can be anything if it wants to be. It can take over the government. Thinking of this as some narrow competition between tech firms, of who is going to get to the next trillion dollars of market cap, is one of the strangest, narrowest ways to think about it.”
Nadella went on to say that the very nature of companies stood to be disrupted in the future. “If intelligence has network effects, what is the future of a firm?” he asked. “If the model sees anything and learns it, and essentially all of human capital collapses into token capital, what is the role of a firm and the human capital in a firm? That’s the debate.”
“I think the political economy is going to get more and more interesting in that context. No one — at least in a democracy — can even win an election if this just goes that way, if there’s only capital and there’s no labor. I mean, I don’t know, that’s not an economy.”
“If the Marxist sort of view is that there’s only one firm, then it’s over, right? For all of us. Not just for me. You are also going to somehow be some affiliate of Anthropic.”
Needless to say, this is not how tech CEOs usually talk about the launch of competing spreadsheet software.
Of course, Nadella was also promoting Microsoft’s various AI tools at Ignite, which promise to let enterprise clients pick the most cost-effective models for various tasks, run their own models, and control their own data in different ways. The idea here is that the market will demand many different kinds of models and sovereign data in order to keep control from centralizing, a theme Nadella kept coming back to as we spoke.
“I think that if you believe that the world, the economy needs more than one firm or two firms, then by definition there need to be as many models as firms of some sort,” he said.