生命起点存在气泡的理由

内容来源:https://www.quantamagazine.org/the-case-for-a-bubble-at-lifes-start-20261110/
内容总结:
生命起源需要“容器”?脂质世界假说引热议
在Quanta杂志“生命起源周”系列报道中,一篇关于“脂质优先”假说的文章引发关注。文章指出,每个细胞本质上都是被膜包裹的化学反应体系,现代细胞每秒可协调约10亿次反应,而即便是最简单的早期细胞也需要物理边界将分子聚集在一起。加州大学圣克鲁兹分校天体生物学家布鲁斯·达默表示:“你需要先有一个容器,才能开展化学过程。”
部分研究者据此提出“脂质优先”假说,认为细胞膜对生命功能至关重要,地球正是借助这些容器从原始化学混沌过渡到可识别的生命形态。更有支持者进一步主张,这些“泡泡”本身也经历了演化。20世纪90年代,研究人员设想:承载可遗传信息并接受演化筛选的,或许不是某个分子,而是一个化学系统。
该设想始于早期地球上的水洼,其中富含多种小有机分子。这些分子一端亲水、一端疏水,在水中自发组装成球形“泡泡”。泡泡内若含有分子A和分子B,二者可互相促进生成,形成维持比例稳定的共生循环。泡泡长大后分裂,将分子按比例分配给子代泡泡,实现组成信息的代际传递。若出现“突变”分子C,则可能改变分子循环,生长更快的泡泡分裂更频繁,逐渐挤占生长慢的泡泡,从而实现自然选择。
2000年,魏茨曼科学研究所遗传学家多伦·兰塞特和波士顿大学计算生物学家丹尼尔·塞格雷发表计算机模型结果,发现泡泡可将组成传递给子代,子代存在差异并相互竞争,满足自然选择条件。在模型中,脂质世界假说至少通过了首轮检验。
然而,在该假说提出25年来,科学家不断质疑最早的分隔结构是否必须由脂质构成。达默表示:“现在已经没有纯粹的脂质世界假说了。”研究者提出,铁硫化物等矿物质可形成容器壁,或凝聚层液滴可作为无膜容器支持早期化学。达默与圣克鲁兹生物化学家戴维·迪默则聚焦温泉池环境,研究反复干湿循环能否促使简单分子在脂质层间发展出更复杂系统。
生命起源研究素来争议激烈。芝加哥大学诺贝尔奖得主、生物化学家杰克·绍斯塔克表示:“仅由脂质构成的原始生命形式这一想法从未让我信服。”他 citing 缺乏脂质系统可演化的实验证据,并指出早期地球如何形成哪怕简单脂质仍是“所有前生命化学中最不成熟的方面”。2010年一项分析还提出,组成信息代际复制误差过大,自然选择难以运作。
不过,这些反对意见均未否定早期生命需要“容器”。即便支持RNA起源说的绍斯塔克也认同脂质优先阵营最核心的观点——分隔结构对维持相关分子聚集必不可少。他表示,没有容器,“达尔文演化就无法运作”。
中文翻译:
生命伊始需要一个泡泡的理由
引言
这篇解释性文章是《量子杂志》“生命起源周”的一部分。请在本周内持续关注,获取更多关于科学界最大未解之谜之一的故事。
从根本上说,每个细胞都只是一个被封在膜内的化学泡泡。在现代细胞中,这种化学过程极其复杂,每秒 orchestrate 约10亿次反应。同样,它的容器——脂质膜——也是由精密的生化机制构建和维护的。但即便是简单得多的最初细胞,也需要一个泡泡。
加州大学圣克鲁兹分校的天体生物学家布鲁斯·达默表示,如果没有物理边界将分子聚集在一个小空间里,无论是什么东西最终演变成了早期生命,都会过于分散,无法组装出生命所需的复杂系统。“你需要一个容器,才能进行化学过程。”
对一些研究人员来说,细胞膜对生命功能如此不可或缺,以至于他们提出细胞膜就是生命的起源。在这一被称为“脂质优先”假说的框架中,地球之所以从一团混沌的原始化学物质转变为可被辨识为有生命的东西,正是因为这些容器。
但许多脂质世界的支持者走得更远。他们认为泡泡所做的不仅仅是容纳化学物质。泡泡本身开始演化。
演化需要一种方式让亲代将性状传递给子代。现代生命通过DNA和RNA等复杂的生化物质来实现这一点,这些物质能够在其序列中编码和复制信息。20世纪90年代,研究人员设想了一种不同的可能性:如果一个化学系统——而非一个分子——能够携带可遗传的信息并成为演化的对象呢?
这个想法始于早期地球上的一滩水。水洼中充满了各种小有机分子,有些是本土产生的,有些是由尘埃和陨石带来的。这些分子中有许多具有双重性格。它们的一端被水吸引,即“亲水性”。另一端则像油一样被水排斥。这些“疏水性”末端会挤在一起躲避水,而亲水性末端则朝外。这些行为使分子形成一个微小的球体——一个泡泡。
原始水洼中还有其他分子,即更简单的原材料,在适当的条件下可以转化为更多的自身。其工作原理如下:想象一个泡泡内含有两种特殊分子——分子A和分子B。每种分子都能加速利用水洼中其他成分的化学反应。在这个例子中,分子A加速产生分子B的化学反应。一段时间后,泡泡中充满了B。这些B反过来又可能加速另一种分子的产生。
有时,某个水洼中B会反过来制造更多的A。A制造更多的B,然后B又制造更多的A。每一种都让另一种源源不断地得到补充,形成一个无休止的循环。含有这些A和B的泡泡会生长,但分子的比例大致保持稳定。
随着时间推移,泡泡会分裂,其分子被分配到子泡泡中。每个子泡泡可能分到一些A和一些B,共生循环将继续运转,比单纯靠随机更忠实地复制亲代的组成配方。与DNA逐字母精确复制不同,这里传递给下一代泡泡的是分子的比例。
但演化需要的不仅仅是遗传。它还需要允许变化的存在。在我们的化学汤中,这种可能性来自一个游离的分子C,它像突变一样将泡泡推入不同的分子循环。生长更快的泡泡分裂得更频繁,排挤掉生长较慢的泡泡,因此快速繁衍的后代将在群体中占据越来越大的份额。慢速配方被淘汰出局。
2000年,魏茨曼科学研究所的遗传学家多伦·兰塞特和波士顿大学的计算生物学家丹尼尔·塞格雷发表了一个计算机模型的结果,该模型探索了这些动态是否能够导致类生命行为。他们发现,泡泡可以将其组成传递给子代,子代之间存在变异和竞争,满足了自然选择的要求。至少在他们计算机模型中,脂质世界的想法通过了第一项测试。
哪些分子能够构建这些泡泡?在最初的模拟中,分子A、B以及其他分子是不同种类的脂质。团队最终选定了脂质——构成现代细胞膜的分子——部分原因是它们符合模型所要求的半疏水、半亲水的特性。当脂质被投入水中时,它们可以组装成双层薄片。在适当条件下,薄片会自行闭合,形成一个内部包裹着一小团水的球体。
但在兰塞特、塞格雷及其同事发表最初的脂质世界假说以来的25年里,科学家们一直在质疑最初的隔室是否一定由脂质构成。其他类型的分子难道不能先形成一个容器吗?“现在已经没有一个明确的脂质世界假说了,”达默说。研究人员提出,某些矿物质(如硫化铁)可能形成了容器的壁,或者凝聚层——分子聚集和浓缩的液体状液滴——可能充当了早期化学的无膜容器。
达默和圣克鲁兹的生物化学家大卫·迪默——他曾与兰塞特和塞格雷合作提出最初的假说——仍然聚焦于脂质,但是在一个特定的环境中:温泉池。他们现在研究的是,这种水池反复干涸和重新注水的过程,是否可能将简单分子挤压在脂质层之间,从而发展出越来越复杂的系统。达默将他们更近期的“温泉假说”视为脂质世界的延伸。
生命起源研究以争议激烈而闻名,该领域的科学家将脂质世界与其他关于生命如何形成的观点进行辩论。“仅由脂质构成的原始生命这一想法从未让我觉得合理,”芝加哥大学的诺贝尔奖得主、生物化学家杰克·索斯塔克说。他举出缺乏实验证据来证明基于脂质的系统能够演化。此外,他说,即便是简单的脂质在早期地球上如何形成,也是“所有前生命化学中发展最不充分的一个方面”。
另一项批评直击最初计算机模拟的核心。2010年的一项分析表明,组成信息从一代到下一代的复制会过于不准确,自然选择无法发挥作用。
然而,这些反对意见没有一个涉及早期生命是否需要泡泡这一问题。即便是索斯塔克——他支持以RNA为基础的生命起源解释——也同意脂质优先阵营最关心的一点:隔室对于将相关分子保持在一起是必要的。他说,没有它们,“达尔文演化就无法运作。”
英文来源:
The Case for a Bubble at Life’s Start
Introduction
This explainer is part of Quanta Magazine’s Origins of Life Week. Check back throughout the week for more stories about one of science’s biggest unknowns.
At its core, every cell is just a bubble of chemistry sealed inside a membrane. In modern cells, that chemistry is extraordinarily complex, orchestrating some 1 billion reactions per second. Likewise, its container, the lipid membrane, is built and maintained by elaborate biochemical mechanisms. But even the much simpler first cells would have needed a bubble too.
Without a physical boundary corralling molecules into a small space, whatever it was that turned into early life would have been too dispersed to assemble the complex systems that life requires, said Bruce Damer, an astrobiologist at the University of California, Santa Cruz. “You need a container before you can get the chemistry.”
To some researchers, the cell membrane seems so essential to life’s functions that they propose it as the origin of life. In this framework, known as the “lipid first” hypothesis, Earth transitioned from a mess of primordial chemistry to something recognizably alive because of those containers.
But many proponents of the lipid world go even further. They argue that the bubbles did more than hold chemistry. The bubbles themselves began to evolve.
Evolution requires a way for parents to pass traits to offspring. Modern life accomplishes this with complex biochemicals such as DNA and RNA, which can encode and copy information in their sequences. In the 1990s, researchers imagined a different possibility: What if a chemical system, rather than a molecule, could carry heritable information and become subject to evolution?
The idea begins with a puddle of water on the early Earth. The puddle is stocked with all kinds of small organic molecules, some homegrown and some delivered by dust and meteorites. Many of these molecules have a split personality. One end of them is drawn to water, or “hydrophilic.” The other is repelled by water in the same way that oil is. These “hydrophobic” ends will huddle together to hide from the water, while the hydrophilic ends will face outward. These behaviors cause the molecules to form a tiny sphere — a bubble.
The primordial puddle also has other molecules, simpler raw ingredients that can, under the correct circumstances, be turned into more of themselves. Here’s how that works: Imagine that a bubble contains two special molecules, molecule A and molecule B. Each of these molecules speeds up a chemical reaction that uses other ingredients in the puddle. Molecule A, in this case, speeds up chemical reactions that produce molecule B. After a while, the bubble fills up with B’s. These, in turn, may speed up the production of another kind of molecule.
Sometimes, there might be a puddle where B’s return the favor and make more A’s. The A’s make more B’s, then the B’s make more A’s. Each type keeps the other topped up in an endless loop. The bubble containing these A’s and B’s will grow, but the ratio of molecules will stay more or less steady.
In time, the bubble will split, and its molecules will be dealt out into its baby bubbles. Each of these may get some A’s and some B’s, and the symbiotic loop will keep running, building the parent’s compositional recipe more faithfully than chance alone would. Unlike with DNA, which is copied exactly, letter by letter, a proportion of molecules gets passed down to the next generation of bubbles.
But evolution needs more than heredity. It needs to allow for change. In our chemical soup, that possibility comes from a stray molecule C, which like a mutation tips a bubble into a different molecular loop. Faster-growing bubbles split more often and crowd out slower-growing bubbles, so the fast-moving descendants will make up a bigger and bigger share of the crowd. Slow recipes get squeezed out.
In 2000, Doron Lancet, a geneticist at the Weizmann Institute of Science, and Daniel Segrè, a computational biologist at Boston University, published the results of a computer model that explored whether these dynamics could lead to lifelike behavior. They found that bubbles can pass their compositions to their daughters, which vary and compete, fulfilling the requirements for natural selection. In their computer model, at least, the lipid-world idea passed its first test.
Which molecules could build these bubbles? In the original simulation, molecules A, B, and the rest would be different kinds of lipids. The team settled on lipids, the molecules that make up modern cell membranes, in part because they mirror the model’s required half-hydrophobic, half-hydrophilic nature. When lipids are dropped into water, they can assemble into double-layered sheets. Under the right conditions, the sheets close in on themselves, forming a sphere with a pocket of water trapped inside.
But in the 25 years since Lancet, Segrè, and their colleagues published the original lipid-world hypothesis, scientists have questioned whether the first compartments had to be made of lipids at all. Couldn’t other types of molecules have formed a container first? “There really isn’t a distinct lipid-world hypothesis anymore,” Damer said. Researchers have proposed that certain minerals, such as iron sulfides, could have formed the walls of a container, or that coacervates — liquidlike droplets where molecules gather and concentrate — could have acted as membrane-free vessels for early chemistry.
Damer and David Deamer, a Santa Cruz biochemist who worked with Lancet and Segrè on the original hypothesis, have stayed focused on lipids, but in a specific setting: hot-spring pools. They now study whether the repeated drying and refilling of such pools could have squeezed simple molecules between layers of lipids to develop increasingly complex systems. Damer views their more recent “hot spring hypothesis” as an extension of the lipid world.
Origins-of-life research is famously contentious, and scientists in the field debate the lipid world against other ideas about how life formed. “The idea of a lipid-only form of primitive life has never made sense to me,” said Jack Szostak, a Nobel Prize–winning biochemist at the University of Chicago. He cited the lack of experimental evidence that a lipid-based system can evolve. Plus, he said, how even simple lipids would have formed on the early Earth is “the least well-developed aspect of all of prebiotic chemistry.”
Another criticism strikes at the heart of the original computer simulation. A 2010 analysis suggested that the replication of compositional information from one generation to the next would be too inaccurate for natural selection to work.
None of these objections, though, is about whether early life needed a bubble. Even Szostak, who favors an RNA-based explanation for the origin of life, agrees on the point that the lipid-first camp cares about most — that compartments are necessary to keep related molecules together. Without them, he said, “Darwinian evolution could not operate.”