生命始于RNA世界吗?

qimuai 发布于 阅读:30 一手编译

生命始于RNA世界吗?

内容来源:https://www.quantamagazine.org/did-life-begin-in-an-rna-world-20261109/

内容总结:

生命起源之谜:RNA世界假说面临挑战

在地球上,生命几乎无处不在,从云层到气候,甚至岩石都受到生物的影响。然而,大约40亿年前,生命如何在荒芜的星球上首次出现,仍是科学界最大的未解之谜之一。许多研究人员认为,自我复制——即可靠地储存和复制遗传信息的能力——是生命最核心的特征。如果这一观点成立,那么最早的生命形式可能需要类似于现代生命用来储存和复制遗传信息的生物分子。

DNA分子在这一过程中扮演核心角色,它编码蛋白质分子的形式,而蛋白质分子则驱动细胞内的化学反应。为了将DNA中的遗传信息转化为蛋白质的化学结构,细胞需要使用RNA。问题在于,在现代细胞中,蛋白质参与了这一过程的每一步:它们在细胞分裂时复制DNA,将DNA转录为RNA,并帮助利用RNA制造更多蛋白质。这就产生了一个“先有鸡还是先有蛋”的困境:没有DNA,细胞无法制造有用的蛋白质;但制造DNA本身又需要蛋白质。

20世纪80年代末关于RNA的一项发现似乎打破了这一僵局。研究人员发现,除了帮助将遗传信息转化为蛋白质外,某些RNA还能作为催化剂促进化学反应。这些RNA被命名为“核酶”,以对应蛋白质催化剂“酶”。核酶的存在表明,RNA既可以携带遗传序列信息,又可以作为催化剂,从而同时承担DNA和蛋白质的功能。这使得一种可能性变得合理:在生命的最早期阶段——或者说在生命出现之前的复杂化学阶段——一切都围绕RNA展开。根据这一图景,由物理学家转行成为生物学家的沃尔特·吉尔伯特提出了“RNA世界”假说,认为生命始于RNA世界。

设想在生命出现前的地球上,某个地方出现了单个核苷酸分子,它们自发地、随机地连接成链。某一天,其中一条核苷酸链偶然获得了正确的序列,成为一种能够帮助其他RNA形成的核酶。这样的前生物核酶甚至可以作为一种自催化剂,具备自我复制的能力。1996年,研究人员制造出一种确实能将单个核苷酸拼接成RNA的核酶,这为该理论提供了支持,也让RNA能够自我复制的前景变得更加可期。

由于这种复制容易受到分子世界随机噪声的干扰,错误在所难免。一些复制出的RNA序列会与其母体略有不同。有了这种突变,达尔文进化就成为可能:自然选择会偏好那些能以更快速度进行复制的突变复制子。

这些原始的、正在进化的分子系统本身并不算“活着”。然而,不难想象某些RNA分子如何进化出催化代谢过程或制造其他复杂生物分子的形式——由此,通往第一批真正活的原始细胞的路径便进入了视野。

“RNA世界”这一概念在理论上听起来不错,但该假说也存在问题。2019年,索尔克研究所的RNA生物学家杰拉尔德·乔伊斯及其同事在实验室中探索了一种制造新核酶的方法。他们首先制造出能够制造其他RNA的合成核酶,然后对这些核酶的序列进行打乱,使其人工进化。尽管他们最终找到了一种能够合成其“进化”来源RNA的核酶,但乔伊斯和同事发现,每一轮进化中引入的突变往往会破坏催化行为。每一代中很少有突变体能够保留构建其他RNA分子的能力。总体而言,这些实验表明,自我维持的RNA进化似乎很难实现。

此外,乔伊斯的所有核酶都很大,大约由几百个连接的核苷酸组成。然而,目前的实验仅能实现相对微小的RNA的自发组装——大约10到15个核苷酸长。从随机组装小的、片段化的RNA,到形成一个能够形成大分子、更不用说复制和进化的大型RNA世界,这是一个巨大的跨越。这类功能性分子随机组装并在某种原始汤中自我维持的概率似乎微乎其微。

但RNA世界的坚定支持者仍有理由保持希望。英国MRC分子生物学实验室的生物学家菲利普·霍利格及其同事的最新研究表明,自我复制的RNA不一定需要像乔伊斯的核酶那么大。在他们自己的RNA人工进化实验中,霍利格团队在小型RNA(长度在20到40个核苷酸之间)中寻找催化活性,并允许每个突变周期中长度发生微小变化。他们发现了一个被命名为QT45(意为“非常小”)的45个核苷酸分子,它能够抓住另一条RNA链并进行复制。霍利格表示:“原则上它可以复制任何序列。”他还补充说,获得一个45个核苷酸的分子“似乎并非不合理的要求”。事实上,研究人员表示,即使QT45被分成两个片段,催化活性也可能得以维持,因为这些部分应该仍然能够各自发挥作用。

研究人员还在大约10万亿个不同分子的起始池中发现了另外两个具有类似活性的类似小型RNA。霍利格表示,鉴于这个数量仅包含该长度所有可能RNA序列的千亿分之一,这实际上是一个相当不错的命中率。这表明,小型RNA中的这种自我复制能力可能足够普遍,以至于这类分子可以在某种原始汤中的随机RNA中很容易地出现。

那个“可以”二字承载了很多不确定性。目前尚不清楚早期地球上是否存在适合RNA世界的生态位——无论是地理上还是时间上。霍利格及其同事已经表明,导致指数增长的RNA复制轮次可以由酸度的周期性变化 coupled with 溶液的冻融循环来驱动——这在年轻地球的冰极地区是一种合理的情景。但任何潜在的栖息地都必须对生命友好足够长的时间,以便生命的火花得以点燃。

也许最重要的是,目前还不清楚RNA世界是否真正“活着”。生命不仅仅是自我复制的遗传信息载体——它需要更多的成分,特别是某种形式的代谢,从环境中获取能量并用于制造有用的分子。无论生命如何起源,它可能需要的不仅仅是一串核苷酸。

中文翻译:

生命始于RNA世界吗?

引言

这篇解释性文章是《量子杂志》“生命起源周”专题的一部分。欢迎在本周内持续关注,了解更多关于科学界最大未解之谜之一的故事。

地球上几乎没有任何角落是生命未曾涉足的。生物体塑造着云层、气候,甚至岩石。但大约40亿年前,生命最初是如何在一个荒芜的星球上出现的,这仍然是科学界最大的问题之一。许多研究人员认为,自我复制——即可靠地储存和复制遗传信息的能力——是生命最核心的能力。如果确实如此,那么最早的生命形式想必需要今天生命用来储存和复制遗传信息的那类生物分子。

DNA分子是这一过程的主角;它编码着能够在细胞中促成化学反应的蛋白质分子的形态。为了将DNA中的遗传信息转化为蛋白质的化学结构,细胞使用RNA。问题在于,在现代细胞中,蛋白质参与了这一过程的每一个步骤:细胞分裂时它们复制DNA,它们将DNA转录为RNA,它们还帮助利用RNA制造更多的蛋白质。这就造成了一个“先有鸡还是先有蛋”的困境:没有DNA,细胞就无法制造有用的蛋白质;但制造DNA从一开始就需要蛋白质。

20世纪80年代末关于RNA的一项发现似乎打破了这一僵局。研究人员发现,除了帮助将遗传信息转化为蛋白质之外,某些RNA还能充当催化剂,促成化学反应。这些RNA被命名为“核酶”,参照的是被称为“酶”的蛋白质催化剂。核酶的存在表明,RNA既能携带遗传序列信息,又能充当催化剂,从而同时承担DNA和蛋白质的职能。这使得以下推测变得合理:在生命的最早期——或者说在生命出现之前的复杂化学阶段——一切都围绕RNA展开。根据这一由图灵奖得主、物理学家转行成为生物学家的沃尔特·吉尔伯特所倡导的图景,生命始于一个RNA世界。

那么想象一下,在前生命地球上的某个地方,单个核苷酸分子出现了,并自发地、随机地连接成链。在某一个重大的日子,其中一条核苷酸链偶然获得了正确的序列,成为一种能够帮助其他RNA形成的核酶。这样的前生命核酶甚至可以充当自催化剂,能够复制自身。1996年,这一理论得到了有力支持——研究人员创造了一种核酶,它确实能够将单个核苷酸拼接在一起形成RNA。这提升了RNA能够自我复制的前景。

由于这种复制容易受到分子世界随机噪声的干扰,错误在所难免。一些复制出的RNA序列会与其母体略有不同。有了这样的突变,达尔文式进化就成为可能:自然选择会偏好那些以更快速度进行复制的突变复制子。

这些原始的、正在进化的分子系统本身并不算“活着”。然而,不难想象某些RNA分子如何进化出催化代谢过程或制造其他复杂生物分子的形态——由此,通往最早真正存活的原始细胞的路径便进入了视野。

“RNA世界”这一概念在理论上听起来不错。但这一假说也存在问题。2019年,索尔克研究所的RNA生物学家杰拉尔德·乔伊斯及其同事探索了一种在实验室中制造新核酶的方法。他们首先创造了能够制造其他RNA的合成核酶,然后对这些核酶的序列进行了一定程度的打乱,让它们人工进化。尽管他们最终找到了一种能够合成其“进化”来源RNA的核酶,但乔伊斯及其同事发现,每一轮进化中引入的突变往往会破坏催化行为。在每一代后续突变体中,能保留构建其他RNA分子能力的极少。总的来说,这些实验表明,自我维持的RNA进化似乎很难实现。

更重要的是,乔伊斯的所有核酶都很大,大约由几百个相连的核苷酸组成。然而,目前的实验只能自发组装出相对微小的RNA——大约10到15个核苷酸长。从随机组装出小型碎片化RNA,到形成一个能够生成大分子、更不用说复制和进化的RNA世界,这中间有着巨大的跨越。像这样有功能的分子随机组装起来、然后在某个原始汤池中自我维持的概率,看起来微乎其微。

但RNA世界的忠实信徒们仍有理由抱有希望。英国MRC分子生物学实验室的生物学家菲利普·霍利格及其同事最近的工作表明,自我复制的RNA不一定非要像乔伊斯的核酶那么大。在他们自己的RNA人工进化实验中,霍利格的团队在小RNA(长度在20到40个核苷酸之间)中寻找催化活性,并允许每个突变周期中长度发生微小变化。他们发现了一个45个核苷酸的分子,将其命名为QT45(“相当小”),它能够抓住另一条RNA链并对其进行复制。霍利格说:“原则上它可以复制任何序列。”他还补充说, spontaneously获得一个45个核苷酸的分子“似乎并非不合理的要求”。事实上,研究人员表示,即使QT45被拆分成两个片段,催化活性也可能得以维持,因为这些部分应该仍然能够各司其职。

研究人员还在大约10万亿个不同分子的起始库中发现了另外两个具有类似活性的、大小相当的RNA。霍利格说,考虑到这么多分子仅仅涵盖了这一长度所有可能RNA序列的千亿分之一,这实际上已经是一个相当不错的命中率了。这表明,小RNA中的这种自我复制能力可能足够普遍,以至于这类分子在某种原始汤中很容易就能从随机RNA中涌现出来。

这个“可能”二字承载了很多分量。目前尚不清楚早期地球上是否存在过RNA世界的生态位——无论是在地理上还是时间上。霍利格及其同事已经证明,导致指数增长的RNA复制轮次可以由酸度的周期性变化以及溶液的冻融循环来驱动——这在年轻地球的极地冰区是一种合理的情景。但任何潜在的栖息地都必须对生命友好足够长的时间,才能让生命的火花点燃。

也许最重要的是,目前并不清楚RNA世界是否真正算得上“活着”。生命不仅仅是自我复制的遗传信息载体——它需要更多的要素,特别是需要某种形式的代谢,从环境中获取能量并用它来制造有用的分子。无论生命是如何开始的,它可能需要的不仅仅是一串核苷酸。

英文来源:

Did Life Begin in an RNA World?
Introduction
This explainer is part of Quanta Magazine’s Origins of Life Week. Check back throughout the week for more stories about one of science’s biggest unknowns.
There’s scarcely any corner of Earth in which life hasn’t gained a foothold. Living organisms shape the clouds, the climate, even the rocks. But how life first appeared on a barren planet some 4 billion years ago remains one of the biggest questions for science. Many researchers believe that self-replication — an ability to reliably store and copy genetic information — is life’s most core ability. If that’s true, then the earliest life-forms would presumably have needed the sorts of biomolecules that life uses to store and copy genetic information today.
The DNA molecule is the star of this process; it encodes the forms of the protein molecules that enable chemical reactions in cells. To translate the genetic information in DNA into the chemical structure of proteins, cells use RNA. The trouble is, in modern cells, proteins are involved in every step of this process: They duplicate DNA when cells divide, they transcribe DNA into RNA, and they help to use RNA for making more proteins. This creates a chicken-and-egg problem: Useful proteins can’t be made in cells without DNA, but proteins are needed to make DNA in the first place.
A discovery about RNA in the late 1980s seemed to break the deadlock. Researchers found that, in addition to helping to convert genetic information into proteins, some RNAs can act as catalysts that enable chemical reactions. These were christened ribozymes, in reference to the protein catalysts called enzymes. The existence of ribozymes suggested that RNA can both carry genetic sequence information and act as a catalyst, thereby doing the jobs of both DNA and proteins. That makes it plausible that in its very earliest days, life — or the complex chemistry that preceded it — was all about RNA. According to this picture, championed by the physicist-turned-biologist Walter Gilbert, life began as an RNA world.
Imagine then that, somewhere on the prebiotic Earth, individual nucleotide molecules appeared and joined together spontaneously and randomly in chains. By chance one momentous day, one of these nucleotide chains acquired the right sequence to act as a ribozyme with the ability to help other RNAs form. Such a prebiotic ribozyme could even act as an autocatalyst, able to replicate itself. In 1996, this theory got a boost when researchers created a ribozyme that could indeed stitch individual nucleotides together to form RNA. This raised the prospect of RNA that could replicate.
Because such replication would be vulnerable to the random noise of the molecular world, errors would happen. Some replicated RNA would have a slightly different sequence from its parent. With such mutations, Darwinian evolution becomes possible: Natural selection would favor mutant replicators that make copies at a faster rate.
These primitive, evolving molecular systems wouldn’t be “alive” in themselves. It’s easy to imagine, however, how some RNA molecules could evolve into forms that catalyzed metabolic processes or made other complex biomolecules — and from there the path to the first truly living protocells comes into view.
The “RNA world,” as the idea was dubbed, sounds good in theory. But there are problems with the hypothesis. In 2019, the RNA biologist Gerald Joyce of the Salk Institute and his colleagues were exploring a method for making new ribozymes in the lab. They started by creating synthetic ribozymes that could make other RNAs. Then they scrambled the ribozymes’ sequences a bit to let them evolve artificially. Although they eventually found a ribozyme capable of synthesizing the RNA from which it had “evolved,” Joyce and colleagues found that the mutations introduced in each round of evolution tended to kill off the catalytic behavior. Very few mutants in each successive generation retained the ability to construct other RNA molecules at all. All told, the experiments suggest that self-sustaining RNA evolution appears to be hard.
What’s more, all of Joyce’s ribozymes were big, comprising perhaps several hundred or so linked nucleotides. However, current experiments have only yielded spontaneous assembly of RNAs that are relatively tiny — about 10 to 15 nucleotides long. It’s big jump to go from random assembly of small, fragmentary RNAs to an RNA world in which large molecules can form, much less replicate and evolve. The chance of functional molecules like these assembling at random and then sustaining themselves in some primordial pool seems minuscule.
But RNA-world true believers have some reason to maintain hope. Recent work from the biologist Philipp Holliger at the MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology in the United Kingdom and his colleagues has shown that self-replicating RNAs don’t have to be as big as Joyce’s ribozymes. In their own RNA artificial evolution experiments, Holliger’s team looked for catalytic activity in small RNAs (between 20 and 40 nucleotides in length), allowing for small changes in length in each cycle of mutation. They found a 45-nucleotide molecule that they christened QT45 (“quite tiny”) that could seize another RNA strand and copy it. “In principle it can copy any sequence,” Holliger said. And getting a 45-nucleotide molecule spontaneously “does not seem an unreasonable ask,” he added. In fact, the researchers say, the catalytic activity might be sustained even if QT45 is split into two fragments, since the parts should remain able to do their jobs.
The researchers also found two other comparably small RNAs with similar activity within a starting pool of around 10 trillion different molecules. Given that this many molecules includes just a hundred-billionth of all the possible RNA sequences of this length, that’s actually a pretty good hit rate, Holliger said. It suggests that this sort of self-copying ability in small RNAs might be common enough that such molecules could have appeared quite readily among random RNAs in some kind of primordial soup.
That “could” is doing a lot of work. It’s not known whether there was a niche for an RNA world, either geographically or temporally, on the early Earth. Holliger and colleagues have shown that rounds of RNA replication leading to exponential growth can be driven by cyclic changes in acidity coupled with cycles of freezing and thawing of the solution — a plausible scenario at the icy poles of the young Earth. But any potential habitat would have to have been life-friendly for long enough for a spark of life to catch.
Perhaps most importantly, it’s not clear that an RNA world would be truly alive. Life isn’t just about self-replicating carriers of genetic information — it takes more ingredients, in particular the existence of some form of metabolism to harvest energy from the environment and use it to make useful molecules. However life started, it probably needed more than just a string of nucleotides.

quanta

文章目录


    扫描二维码,在手机上阅读