西雅图市长解除暂停令,将在新保障措施下扩大警方监控摄像头

内容总结:
西雅图市长凯蒂·威尔逊周二宣布,将把警察监控摄像头网络扩展至另外三个社区,结束了她今年3月因隐私和公民自由顾虑而实施的暂停令。这一决定是在纽约大学警务项目发布对西雅图警察局实时犯罪中心的独立审计报告一天后作出的。该审计由威尔逊在暂停期间委托进行,结论是西雅图已为该系统的监管“建立了重要基础”,但“仍存在显著的政策空白”,并提出了19项建议。
根据市长办公室的消息,体育场区在夏季国际足联世界杯前安装的摄像头将立即启用。加菲尔德高中周边和国会山夜生活区的摄像头仍需采购和安装,预计耗时数月。市议会已于2025年批准了这三个区域。威尔逊在世界杯期间曾短暂启用体育场区域的22个摄像头,理由是执法部门报告了“可信威胁”,并表示赛事结束后将关闭。审计指出,警方在整个赛事期间实时调取了视频流,尽管部门政策规定不得在没有活跃报警或案件的情况下监控摄像头。
威尔逊在声明中表示:“在审查了证据、建议以及我们可用的保障措施后,我认为实时犯罪中心在西雅图的公共安全体系中可以发挥重要且负责任的作用。”她表示,市府将采纳审计的大部分建议。警察局将公开发布关于犯罪中心使用情况的仪表板,并收紧数据保留、允许用途及外部机构请求方面的规定。一个新设的咨询小组将协助制定有关私人摄像头、抗议活动及未来摄像头布点的政策。
实时犯罪中心于2025年启动,将数百个摄像头的实时视频汇入警察总部的单一指挥室。其中包括分布在61个地点的303个警方自有摄像头、警察建筑内的116个安全摄像头、96个城市交通摄像头,以及3家本地企业共享给警方的23个摄像头。分析人员接听911报警电话时同步调取附近摄像头,为警员提供报警人可能遗漏的细节,如嫌疑人穿着或逃跑方向。他们还会梳理录像以协助侦探调查已发生的犯罪。该系统运行在亚利桑那州警用执法记录仪和泰瑟枪制造商Axon的Fusus软件上。
警方被禁止在该系统中使用人脸识别。软件确实包含一款可在视频中搜索人员、车辆及其他物体的AI工具,但分析人员告诉审计人员,他们仅将其作为最后手段使用,因为该工具不可靠。在一个案例中,搜索一名穿灰色上衣和灰色裤子的男子,返回的却是一只鸽子的图像。
该系统能否减少犯罪仍是未知数。西雅图警察局表示,借助犯罪中心分析人员的协助,警员和侦探实施逮捕的可能性提高了三倍,该中心在2025年协助处理了17起凶杀案,帮助破获10起。但审计指出,该部门将分析人员的任何操作都计为“支持”,例如查看摄像头,即使没有产生有用信息。审计发现,关于犯罪中心的更广泛研究较为匮乏,而单独针对监控摄像头的研究结果喜忧参半。宾夕法尼亚大学受该市监察长委托对西雅图项目进行的评估预计要到2027年底才能完成。
批评者警告称,录像可能最终落入联邦移民执法人员或外州检察官手中,用于追究来华盛顿州寻求堕胎或性别肯定医疗的人。审计发现,州法和市法对此类共享有限制,但无法完全阻止。外部机构仍可通过公共记录请求或法院命令从市府或Axon获取录像,Axon将警察局的部分视频存储在其云端。华盛顿州美国公民自由联盟技术政策项目主任蒂·萨农表示,该组织对这一决定“深感失望”。萨农说,审计“再次确认了隐私保护和问责方面的显著空白”,扩展网络“是朝着错误方向迈出的一步”。她补充说,市府应投资于经过验证的替代方案,如社区暴力预防项目。萨农表示:“闭路电视和实时犯罪中心配合使用,会极大增强执法部门在全城监控、追踪和还原人员行动的能力。”她说,保护居民需要对技术使用方式、数据保留时长和共享对象实施严格且可执行的限制,并建立独立监督。
威尔逊表示,扩展网络与新的保障措施是相辅相成的。她说:“我们可以收集证据,追究暴力行为者的责任,同时保护我们的邻居免受联邦越权行为的侵害。”商业团体对此决定表示赞赏。西雅图市中心协会总裁兼首席执行官乔恩·斯科尔斯表示,该市“已经建立了严格的隐私防护栏”,而在警察人手“仍然不足”的情况下,额外工具“对破案至关重要”。西雅图大都会商会和挑战西雅图组织曾推动市府启用摄像头,他们引用了今年委托进行的一项民调,显示75%的西雅图选民支持使用摄像头协助正在进行的调查。前州长、挑战西雅图组织首席执行官克里斯·格雷瓜尔表示:“居民和企业已发出明确信号:他们希望我们的警员拥有保障安全的工具。”市议会公共安全委员会主席、市议员鲍勃·凯特尔表示,委员会将审议审计建议以及市监察长和审计长的建议。
据市长办公室消息,市府还计划为将西雅图中心租户和附近企业的摄像头接入犯罪中心奠定基础,并援引了这些企业在7月“西雅图美食节”枪击案后表现出的兴趣。审计将私人摄像头整合列为需要关注的关键领域:警察局已购买了约100台设备,可让企业将视频流传输至中心,但尚未决定由谁获得这些设备。咨询小组将包括社区警察委员会、社区监控工作组成员、警方及其他市府工作人员,将在未来几个月内召开会议。其建议随后将进入警察局的政策审查流程。
中文翻译:
西雅图市长凯蒂·威尔逊周二表示,该市将把警察监控摄像头网络扩展至另外三个街区,从而结束了她在三月份因隐私和公民自由方面的担忧而实施的暂停令。
这一决定作出前一天,纽约大学警务项目发布了对西雅图警察局实时犯罪中心(RTCC)的独立审计报告,该审计由威尔逊在暂停期间委托进行。审计发现,该市已为监督该系统建立了“重要基础”,但“仍存在重大政策缺口”。审计提出了19项建议。
据市长办公室消息,体育场区在本届国际足联世界杯之前安装的摄像头将立即启用。加菲尔德高中周边以及国会山夜生活区的摄像头仍需采购和安装,这将需要数月时间。市议会在2025年批准了全部三个区域的摄像头部署。
威尔逊在世界杯期间曾短暂启用体育场区域的22个摄像头,理由是执法部门报告了“可信威胁”,并表示赛事结束后将关闭。审计指出,警方在整个赛事期间持续调取实时画面,尽管部门政策禁止在没有活跃报警或案件的情况下监控摄像头。
威尔逊在声明中表示:“在审查了证据、建议以及我们可用的保障措施之后,我认为RTCC在西雅图的公共安全体系中可以发挥重要且负责任的作用。”
威尔逊表示,该市将采纳审计的大部分建议。警察局将发布关于犯罪中心使用情况的公开看板,并收紧有关数据保留、允许用途及外部机构请求的规定。一个新的咨询小组将协助制定有关私人摄像头、抗议活动以及未来摄像头部署位置的政策。
实时犯罪中心于2025年启动,将数百个摄像头的实时视频汇集到警察总部的一个指挥室中。其中包括分布在61个地点的303个警方自有摄像头、警察建筑内的116个安防摄像头、96个城市交通摄像头,以及3家当地企业拥有的23个摄像头——这些企业主动与警方共享画面。
分析人员实时监听911报警电话,调取附近摄像头画面,为警员提供报警人可能遗漏的细节,例如嫌疑人的穿着或逃跑方向。他们还会梳理录像资料,协助侦探调查已发生的犯罪案件。该系统运行在Fusus平台上,该软件由总部位于亚利桑那州的Axon公司开发,该公司生产警用执法记录仪和泰瑟枪。
警方被禁止在该系统中使用人脸识别技术。该软件确实包含一个AI工具,可在视频中搜索人员、车辆及其他物体,但分析人员告诉审计人员,他们仅将此作为最后手段,因为该工具并不可靠。在一个案例中,搜索一名身穿灰色上衣和灰色裤子的男子,结果返回了一张鸽子的图片。
该系统是否能减少犯罪仍是一个未解的问题。西雅图警察局表示,在犯罪中心分析人员的协助下,警员和侦探实施逮捕的可能性提高了三倍,该中心在2025年协助处理了17起凶杀案,帮助破获了其中10起。但审计指出,警察局将分析人员的任何操作都计为“支持”,例如查看摄像头,即使并未产生有用信息。
审计发现,关于犯罪中心的更广泛研究十分匮乏,而单纯针对监控摄像头的研究也显示出好坏参半的结果。宾夕法尼亚大学受该市监察长委托对西雅图项目进行的评估,预计要到2027年底才能完成。
批评者警告称,录像资料最终可能落入联邦移民执法人员或外州检察官手中,用于追诉那些来到华盛顿州寻求堕胎或性别肯定医疗护理的人。审计发现,州法和市法对此类共享有所限制,但无法完全杜绝。外部机构仍可通过公开记录请求或法院命令从该市或Axon公司获取录像——Axon在其云端存储了警察局的部分视频。
华盛顿州美国公民自由联盟技术政策项目主任蒂·桑农表示,该组织对这一决定“深感失望”。桑农说,审计“再次确认了隐私保护和问责方面存在重大缺口”,扩展网络“是朝着错误方向迈出的一步”。她补充说,该市应投资于经过验证的替代方案,例如社区暴力预防项目。
桑农说:“闭路电视和RTCC结合使用,极大地增强了执法部门在整个城市监控、追踪和还原人员活动的能力。”她表示,要保护居民,需要对技术的使用方式、数据保留时长和共享对象设置严格且可执行的限制,并配合独立监督。
威尔逊表示,网络扩展与新的保障措施是相辅相成的。她说:“我们可以收集证据,追究实施暴力行为者的责任,同时保护我们的邻居免遭联邦越权行为的侵害。”
商业团体对这一决定表示赞赏。西雅图市中心协会总裁兼首席执行官乔恩·斯科尔斯表示,该市“已经建立了严格的隐私防护措施”,而在警察人手“仍然不足”的情况下,额外的工具“对破案至关重要”。西雅图大都会商会和Challenge Seattle一直推动该市启用摄像头,他们引用了今年委托进行的一项民调,该民调发现75%的西雅图选民支持使用摄像头协助正在进行的调查。
“居民和企业已经发出了明确信号:他们希望我们的警员拥有保障安全所需的工具,”前州长、Challenge Seattle首席执行官克里斯·格雷瓜尔说。
市议员鲍勃·凯特尔担任市议会公共安全委员会主席,他表示该委员会将审议审计的建议,以及市监察长和审计长的建议。
据市长办公室消息,该市还计划为将西雅图中心租户和附近企业运营的摄像头接入犯罪中心奠定基础,并援引了这些企业在七月份“西雅图美食节”枪击事件后表现出的兴趣。审计将私人摄像头的整合列为需要关注的关键领域:警察局已购买了约100台设备,可让企业将视频流传输至中心,但尚未决定由谁获得这些设备。
该咨询小组将包括社区警察委员会、社区监控工作组的成员,以及警察和其他市政工作人员,将在未来几个月内召开会议。其建议随后将进入警察局的政策审查流程。
英文来源:
Seattle will expand its police surveillance camera network to three more neighborhoods, Mayor Katie Wilson said Tuesday, ending a pause she put in place in March over privacy and civil liberties concerns.
The move comes a day after NYU’s Policing Project released an independent audit of the Seattle Police Department’s Real Time Crime Center (RTCC), which Wilson commissioned during the pause. The audit found the city had built “an important foundation” for overseeing the system but that “significant policy gaps remain.” It made 19 recommendations.
Cameras in the Stadium District, installed before this summer’s FIFA World Cup, will be turned on immediately, according to the mayor’s office. Cameras around Garfield High School and in the Capitol Hill nightlife district still need to be bought and installed, which will take months. The City Council approved all three areas in 2025.
Wilson briefly turned on the 22 stadium-area cameras during the World Cup, citing “credible threats” reported by law enforcement, and said they would go off after the tournament. The audit noted that police streamed live feeds throughout the event, despite a department policy against monitoring cameras without an active call or case.
“After reviewing the evidence, the recommendations, and the safeguards available to us, I believe there is an important and responsible role for the RTCC within Seattle’s public-safety system,” Wilson said in a statement.
Wilson said the city will adopt most of the audit’s recommendations. The police department will publish a public dashboard on how the crime center is used and tighten its rules on data retention, permissible uses and requests from outside agencies. A new advisory group will help write policies for privately owned cameras, protests and where future cameras go.
The Real Time Crime Center, which launched in 2025, pulls live video from hundreds of cameras into a single command room at police headquarters. They include 303 police-owned cameras at 61 sites, 116 security cameras at police buildings, 96 city traffic cameras, and 23 cameras owned by three local businesses that share their feeds with police.
Analysts watch 911 calls as they come in and pull up nearby cameras to give officers details callers may have missed, such as what a suspect is wearing or which way they ran. They also comb through recorded footage to help detectives investigate past crimes. The system runs on Fusus, software from Axon, the Arizona-based maker of police body cameras and Tasers.
Police are barred from using facial recognition with the system. The software does include an AI tool that searches video for people, vehicles and other objects, but analysts told auditors they use it only as a last resort because it is unreliable. In one case, a search for a man in a gray top and gray pants returned an image of a pigeon.
Whether the system reduces crime remains an open question. The Seattle Police Department has said officers and detectives are three times more likely to make an arrest with help from crime center analysts, and that the center assisted in 17 homicide cases in 2025, helping close 10. But the audit notes that the department counts any analyst action as “support,” such as checking a camera, even if it produced nothing useful.
Broader research on crime centers is thin, the audit found, and studies of surveillance cameras on their own show mixed results. A University of Pennsylvania evaluation of Seattle’s program, commissioned by the city’s inspector general, isn’t expected until late 2027.
Critics have warned that footage could end up with federal immigration agents or out-of-state prosecutors pursuing people who come to Washington for abortions or gender-affirming care. The audit found that state and city laws limit such sharing, but they can’t fully prevent it. Outside agencies could still get footage through public records requests or court orders served on the city or on Axon, which stores some of the police department’s video in its cloud.
Tee Sannon, technology policy program director for the ACLU of Washington, said the group was “deeply disappointed” by the decision. With the audit having “reaffirmed significant gaps in privacy protections and accountability,” expanding the network “is a step in the wrong direction,” Sannon said. She added that the city should invest in proven alternatives such as community violence prevention programs.
“Used together, CCTV and RTCC supercharge law enforcement’s capabilities to monitor, track, and reconstruct people’s movements across the city,” Sannon said. Protecting residents, she said, requires strict, enforceable limits on how the technology is used, how long data is kept and who it’s shared with, along with independent oversight.
Wilson said the expansion and the new safeguards go together. “We can gather evidence to hold those who commit violent acts accountable and protect our neighbors targeted by federal overreach,” she said.
Business groups praised the decision. Jon Scholes, president and CEO of the Downtown Seattle Association, said the city “already has stringent privacy guardrails in place” and that, with police staffing “still lagging,” additional tools “are essential for solving crimes.” The Seattle Metro Chamber and Challenge Seattle, which have pushed the city to turn on the cameras, cited a poll they commissioned this year that found 75% of Seattle voters support using cameras to help active investigations.
“Residents and businesses have sent a clear message: they want our officers to have the tools to keep them safe,” said former Gov. Chris Gregoire, CEO of Challenge Seattle.
City Councilmember Bob Kettle, who chairs the council’s public safety committee, said the committee will take up the audit’s recommendations, along with those from the city’s inspector general and auditor.
The city also plans to lay groundwork for connecting cameras run by Seattle Center tenants and nearby businesses to the crime center, according to the mayor’s office, citing interest from those businesses after the Bite of Seattle shooting in July. The audit flagged private camera integration as a key area to watch: the police department has bought about 100 devices that let businesses stream video to the center but hasn’t decided who will get them.
The advisory group, which will include members of the Community Police Commission, the Community Surveillance Working Group, police and other city staff, will meet over the next few months. Its recommendations will then go through the police department’s policy review process.
文章标题:西雅图市长解除暂停令,将在新保障措施下扩大警方监控摄像头
文章链接:https://news.qimuai.cn/?post=5536
本站文章均为原创,未经授权请勿用于任何商业用途