AI DJ完全破坏了我的心流

内容来源:https://www.wired.com/story/ai-djs-completely-kill-my-groove/
内容总结:
音乐流媒体平台油管音乐(YouTube Music)推出的AI DJ功能“Beyond the Beat”在歌曲间隙插入约30秒的AI生成解说,负责烘托氛围并介绍下一首曲目。该功能通过YouTube Labs测试项目向用户开放,自2025年上线以来,越来越多听众在音乐应用中接触到此类合成语音解说。Spotify早在2023年就推出了类似工具,并于去年11月扩展了AI DJ的不同“人格”选项和评论控制功能。
然而,这些AI DJ的体验并不理想。作者在晨间锻炼时播放流行女歌手歌单,AI DJ在Slayyyter歌曲后插入了一段冗长的解说,内容空洞、堆砌辞藻,还将独立歌手Charli XCX的名字读错为“Charli XXC”。另一次,AI DJ深入解读了Olivia Rodrigo与Chappell Roan合作的混音版歌曲含义,称其探讨了“酷儿约会的微妙之处”,但随后播放的却是没有Roan参与的原版曲目。
作者随后升级Spotify高级会员以体验其AI DJ功能,发现Spotify新增了八种英语语音选项,但多个语音刻意使用“you know”“like”等口头禅以模仿人类说话方式,反而产生“恐怖谷”效应。总体而言,Spotify的AI解说比油管音乐更为紧凑可忍,但两者均未达到令人愿意持续使用的程度。两家公司的AI语音本身质量尚可、听起来足够像真人,真正令人反感的是解说内容——无论是空洞的套话还是刻意模仿人类口误,都让人听够了。尽管Spotify声称“80%的听众每周都会回来使用DJ功能”,作者表示自己不会成为其中之一。好在两项功能均为可选,用户可以自行关闭。
中文翻译:
我通常无法准确指出自己是从哪一刻开始不再使用某个软件功能的,大多数工具就这样悄然过时,没有明确的终止日期。但YouTube Music的“Beyond the Beat”是个例外——这是一个AI生成的DJ,会为你讲解歌曲。
YouTube Music是我常用的音乐流媒体服务。作为一名软件记者,我总是会开启YouTube Labs提供的测试功能,“Beyond the Beat”就是其中之一。YouTube的AI DJ会在歌曲之间随机插入约30秒的解说,为下一首歌铺垫氛围并提供背景信息。
越来越多的听众在音乐流媒体应用中遇到合成解说。YouTube在2025年推出了这一实验性AI DJ功能,而Spotify早在2023年就率先推出了类似工具。去年11月,Spotify进一步加大了AI DJ的投入,扩展了用户可选的不同“人格”风格,并增加了对解说内容的更多控制选项。
这些AI DJ不只是烦人。它们试图提供有用的背景信息、模仿人类的坦率,但最终效果都很失败。好在我还算幸运,这两个功能都是可选的,可以避开。
在开启该功能数月之后,本周一次糟糕的“Beyond the Beat”体验让我下定决心彻底弃用AI DJ。我当时正在晨练时听一个流行天后歌单,在一首Slayyyter的歌之后,突然被塞了30秒的解说:
“《Hey Boy》完美地释放了那种高能量的冲击力,但我们现在把焦点转向一个更锐利、更赤裸的现实。在《Rock Music》中,Charli XXC(原文如此)融入了一种尖刻的黑色幽默,讲述她在2024和2025年不间断巡演中身体所承受的代价。她将巡演途中真实遭受的神经损伤转化为一种奇特的战斗伤疤,把疲惫派对女孩的倦怠重新定义为荣誉勋章。这是对奇观背后代价的一次毫不遮掩的审视,行业的碾磨本身成为了真正的主题。接下来请听Charli XXC(原文如此)的《Rock Music》。”
好一大段空洞的套话,没什么实质内容。更别提AI DJ还把一个小众独立音乐人Charli XCX的名字念错了。这个小插曲反映了我对YouTube Music AI DJ的整体体验——它把我从音乐的氛围中拉了出来,丝毫没有加分。
再举一个例子,它深入解读了Olivia Rodrigo与Chappell Roan合作的《Expectations》混音版的含义,称其为一种“结构性诠释”,拆解了“酷儿约会中的微妙之处”。然后YouTube Music播放的却是原版曲目,根本没有Roan的参与——所谓的酷儿渴望也不过如此。
出于好奇,想看看Spotify的AI DJ体验与之相比如何,我把账户升级到了高级会员以使用该测试软件。Spotify AI DJ近期最大的变化之一是为阵容增加了新的声音,于是我进入设置,逐一播放了八个英语声音的介绍片段。
也许是因为之前在YouTube Music的体验已经让我有些恼火,这些声音立刻开始让我烦躁。多个人声在AI描述接下来要播放的歌曲时,大量使用“你知道吧”和“就像”之类的口头禅。知道AI声音被训练使用口头禅来让自己听起来更像人类,这给了我一种恐怖谷效应带来的不适感。
Spotify的AI DJ与YouTube Music的版本相当不同。在Spotify上,AI DJ同样是一种算法引导的体验,根据过去的收听习惯和点歌请求为你选歌。总体而言,Spotify的合成解说比YouTube那个喋喋不休的DJ更紧凑、更容易接受。话虽如此,两种软件体验都不足以让我愿意继续使用。
尽管Spotify在公司发布博客中声称“80%的听众每周都会回到DJ功能”,但我不会是其中之一。我对AI DJ的拒绝并非基于它们的听觉效果。两家公司的声音都还不错,听起来像真人。真正让我反感的是它们解说的内容。无论是空洞的套话还是模仿人类的错误,我已经听够了。
评论
返回顶部
英文来源:
I usually can’t pinpoint the moment I stop using a software feature, with most tools drifting out of fashion without an expiration date. That’s not the case with YouTube Music’s “Beyond the Beat,” an AI-generated DJ that explains songs to you.
YouTube Music is my music-streaming service of choice. And since I’m a software reporter, I always enable the beta features available through YouTube Labs, which include Beyond the Beat. YouTube’s AI DJ randomly interjects for about 30 seconds between songs, teeing up the vibe shift and providing context about the next track.
More listeners are encountering synthetic commentary built into their music streaming apps. While YouTube launched this experimental AI DJ in 2025, Spotify first introduced a similar tool back in 2023. It doubled down on its AI DJ efforts in November, expanding the different personalities available to users and adding more controls over the commentary.
These AI DJs aren’t just annoying. Their attempts to provide helpful context and mimic human candor ultimately fall flat. Lucky for me, both features are optional and avoidable.
After months of leaving it enabled, a bad experience with Beyond the Beat this week pushed me to swear off AI DJs altogether. I was listening to a pop divas playlist as part of my morning workout and got slapped with 30 seconds of exposition after a Slayyyter track:
“Hey Boy delivers that high-energy surge perfectly, but we're shifting our focus to a sharper, more visceral reality. In Rock Music, Charli XXC [sic] weaves in a biting, dark sense of humor regarding the physical toll of her relentless 2024 and 2025 touring. She turns the genuine nerve damage she sustained on the road into a strange sort of battle scar, reclaiming the exhaustion of a weary party girl as a badge of honor. It's an unflinching look at the cost behind the spectacle, where the grind of the industry becomes the actual subject matter. Here is Rock Music by Charli XXC [sic].”
What a lengthy paragraph of platitudes with little substance. That’s not even mentioning how the AI DJ butchered the pronunciation of a little-known, indie act called Charli XCX. This flub reflected my overall experience with YouTube Music’s AI DJ. It took me out of the groove and didn’t feel additive.
In another example, it went in-depth on the meaning of Olivia Rodrigo’s Expectations remix featuring Chappell Roan, calling it a "structural interpretation” that unpacks the “nuances of queer dating.” Then YouTube Music played the original track, sans Roan; so much for the queer yearning.
Curious how Spotify’s AI DJ experience would compare, I upgraded my account to the premium tier for access to that beta software. One of the biggest recent changes to Spotify’s AI DJ was adding new voices to the lineup, so I went into my settings and played the introduction clips for each of the eight English-language voices.
Maybe I was already a bit miffed from my YouTube Music experience because these voices immediately started to frustrate me. Multiple voices leaned into filler words such as “you know” and “like,” as the AI described the next songs it would play. Knowing an AI voice is being trained to use filler words to sound more human gave me the uncanny-valley ick.
Spotify’s AI DJ was fairly different from YouTube Music’s version. On Spotify, the AI DJ is also an algorithmically guided experience that picks songs for you based on past listening habits and song requests. Overall, Spotify’s synthetic commentary felt tighter and more tolerable than YouTube’s blabbering DJ. That said, neither software experience was enjoyable enough for me to return.
Although Spotify claims it has “80 percent of listeners coming back to DJ week after week,” according to the company’s launch blog, I won’t be one of them. My rejection of AI DJs isn’t based on how they audibly sound. The voices, from both companies, are decent and sound convincingly human. The content of their commentary is what truly turns me off. Whether it’s empty platitudes or mimicking human mistakes, I’ve heard enough.
Comments
Back to top